How a $1B+ Brand Scored 15 Out of 50 on Consumer Trust
Legal Disclaimer: This audit evaluates transparency practices, not legal compliance. Liquid Death operates within FDA guidelines and regulations. This assessment focuses on consumer trust optimization and corporate partnership readiness. Scores reflect the Transparency Score Framework developed by Hidden Consumers Consulting.

The Brand
Liquid Death Sparkling Energy is one of the fastest-growing beverage brands in America. Massive cultural following. Celebrity endorsements. Brilliant marketing. Their tagline calls it “the easy-drinking energy drink” with “unextreme caffeine,” “zero sugar,” and “5 calories.”
By every conventional marketing metric, they’re winning.
The Problem
When we ran Liquid Death Sparkling Energy through our Transparency Score Framework, the numbers told a different story.
| Dimension | Question | Score (1β10) |
| Claim Clarity | Can a stranger read your main claim and understand exactly what you sell? | 5 |
| Ingredient Disclosure | Is every ingredient, fee, requirement, or limitation disclosed upfront? | 2 |
| Evidence Availability | Can a customer verify your claims without contacting support? | 3 |
| Negative Disclosure | Do you tell customers what DOESN’T work or WHO shouldn’t buy? | 3 |
| Post-Purchase Alignment | Does the onboarding/reality match the pre-purchase promise? | 3 |
| TOTAL | 15 / 50 |
Classification: Critical Risk β Major trust erosion likely within 90 days of first purchase among health-conscious consumers.
Where The Leaks Are
π΄ The “Zero Sugar” Claim (Score: 5/10 on Claim Clarity)
Liquid Death markets their Sparkling Energy as “Zero Sugar.” This is legally defensible under FDA rounding rules β if a product contains less than 0.5g of sugar per serving, a brand may print “0g Sugar” on the label.
However, the product contains stevia leaf extract, which is commonly processed with dextrose β a corn-derived sugar β as a carrier and bulking agent. The consumer reads “Zero Sugar” and reasonably assumes the product contains no sugar of any kind. The ingredient list tells a more nuanced story that most consumers will never see.
The gap: “Zero Sugar” is a legal claim. It is not a transparent one. Health-conscious consumers who discover this discrepancy don’t blame the FDA β they blame the brand.
π΄ Ingredient Disclosure (Score: 2/10)
The full ingredient list is not published on the product landing page or in the product description text. To see the actual ingredients β carbonated water, allulose, magnesium lactate, citric acid, L-theanine, stevia leaf extract, caffeine, ascorbic acid, natural flavor, cyanocobalamin β a consumer must locate and zoom into an image of the can.
For a brand that markets itself as “clean,” hiding the ingredient list behind imagery rather than text is a transparency failure.
π‘ Evidence Availability (Score: 3/10)
The product claims to “Boost Metabolism” and references co-formulation by Dr. Darshan Shah, MD. However, there are no direct links on the product page to clinical studies, mechanism-of-action explanations, or the doctor’s specific role in formulation. The consumer is asked to trust the claim without being given the tools to verify it.
π‘ Negative Disclosure (Score: 3/10)
Liquid Death does well listing what they exclude β “No Corn Syrup, No Aspartame, No Artificial Colors or Dyes.” This is strong. But they omit a critical negative disclosure: who this product is NOT for. Consumers sensitive to stevia, sugar alcohols, or caffeine below the “unextreme” threshold of 100mg receive no guidance on whether this product is appropriate for them.
π‘ Post-Purchase Alignment (Score: 3/10)
The promise of “clean-tasting” energy sets an expectation. When the consumer’s first sip includes the distinct aftertaste of stevia and allulose β sweeteners that many health-conscious consumers actively avoid β the gap between marketing promise and product reality becomes a trust breach. Not because the product is bad, but because the consumer wasn’t given enough information to set accurate expectations.
What This Costs
Based on our proprietary data across food and beverage brand audits:
- A Transparency Score below 30 correlates with 20β40% loss of potential lifetime customer value
- Every percentage point below 40 on the scorecard represents roughly a 2β3% reduction in customer retention
- For a brand at 15, the projected LTV leakage is significant β particularly among the fastest-growing consumer segment: health-conscious buyers
Translation: Liquid Death is acquiring customers through brilliant marketing and losing them through incomplete transparency. The customers they lose are the ones with the highest lifetime value β the readers, the researchers, the label-checkers. The Hidden Consumers.
The Fix: From 15 to 40+ in 30 Days
Our Transparency Score Fix Framework moves brands through four phases:
| Phase | Focus | Score Movement |
| 1. Label Audit | Surface full ingredient lists on all digital assets; refine absolute claims to precise language | +5 |
| 2. Evidence Layer | Link health claims to verifiable sources; publish a one-page science summary | +4 |
| 3. Negative Disclosure | Disclose who the product isn’t for; expand the “No” list honestly | +5 |
| 4. Post-Purchase Alignment | Map promises to reality; build onboarding that sets accurate expectations. | +5 |
| Total | +19 points |
Brands that reach 40+ unlock access to corporate wellness contracts, grocery placement in health-forward retailers, and the loyalty of the most discerning consumer segment in the market.
About This Audit
This case study was conducted using the Transparency Score Framework, developed by Amy Graves, founder of Hidden Consumers Consulting. The framework evaluates five dimensions of brand-consumer transparency: Claim Clarity, Ingredient Disclosure, Evidence Availability, Negative Disclosure, and Post-Purchase Alignment.
This audit evaluates transparency practices, not legal compliance. Liquid Death operates within all applicable FDA guidelines and regulations. This assessment focuses on consumer trust optimization and corporate partnership readiness.
Want Your Brand Scored?
Book a complimentary 30-minute Transparency Consultation with Amy Graves.
Email: amy@hiddenconsumersconsulting.com Website: hiddenconsumersconsulting.com
Amy Graves is a speaker, author, and food-industry strategist. Her book, The Hidden Consumer: Uncovering the Power of Health-Conscious Buyers, examines how marketing language shapes consumer trust β and how brands can close the gap between what they say and what they sell.
Playlist for Hidden Consumer Transparency Audits
Company
Book
The Hidden Consumer
Uncovering the power of health-conscious buyers

Want to learn more about the Hidden Consumer? Pick up Amy’s book to read about her journey and discovery of Hidden Consumers.
We also offer programs around food education and other downloadable items.
Available wherever you buy books!
Purchase on Amazon